Detecting And Describing Preventive Intervention Effects
Detecting and Describing Preventive Intervention Effects in a Universal School-Based Randomized Trial Targeting Delinquent and Violent BehaviorMike Stoolmiller
Oregon Social Learning Center
Eugene, Oregon
J. Mark Eddy
Oregon Social Learning Center
Eugene, Oregon
John B. Reid
Oregon Social Learning Center
Eugene, Oregon
INTRODUCTION
I chose to summarize this article regarding the study of measurement of child aggression in empirical studies, because of the difficulty of conducting such studies. Here I summarize the article I studied, along with comments and my opinions on the findings.
Summary
This study examined theoretical, methodological, and statistical problems involved in evaluating the outcome of aggression on the playground for a universal preventive intervention for conduct disorder. Moderately aggressive children were hypothesized most likely to benefit. Aggression was measured on the playground using observers blind to the group status of the children. Behavior was microcoded in real time to minimize potential expectancy biases. The effectiveness of the intervention was strongly related to initial levels of aggressiveness. The most aggressive children improved the most.
First, participants are clustered within naturally occurring units (e.g., classroom, grade level, or school), and such nonindependence may significantly bias statistical tests of intervention outcome. For example, the aggressive behaviors of children might be observed on the playground for three 10-min observations conducted over a 3-week period at preintervention and three 10-min sessions 6 months later postintervention. The second component is due to true time-specific individual differences across children. Clearly, any true time-specific individual differences in behavior must be the result of time-specific, contextual determinants of aggressive behavior in the external social environment, the internal biological environment, or some combination or interaction of the two. Further,...
View Full Essay