Preview

Female Mill Workers in England and Japan: How Similar Were Their Experiences?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
533 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Female Mill Workers in England and Japan: How Similar Were Their Experiences?
Female mill workers in England and Japan: How similar were their experiences?

Nikita Thompson B period 10/6/11 If a person who thinks they have it tough with their job takes a look at the fact that a young Japanese or British girl worked longer hours, got paid less, and put up with horrendous working conditions, that person might reconsider their statement. Despite the fact that Japan and England had many similarities with female mill workers, they still had a few differences. Young children and women worked in big dangerous factories known as mills, spent more hours then the average working person today, making thread or fixing machines. So how were their experiences different? Female Japanese workers had to work more, got paid less, and accepted the role that their society gave them. Compared to English women mill workers, Japanese women worked more. English female workers only worked about 74 hours a week and Japanese female workers worked 91 hours a week (Document 5). This was because the Japanese workers worked longer each day, had fewer holidays, and worked on weekends (Document 5). English female workers had more breaks, worked shorter hours each day, and did not work on weekends. This is a big difference between female English and Japanese mill workers. Even though in both England and Japan women got paid less than men, Japanese women got paid even less than English women. This is why they had so many workers (document 4). Since Japan paid the female mill workers less, they would be able to hire more workers and increase their production rate. Why would they want to pay women less? They paid women less because the women needed money and they would accept any amount given to them (Document 8). Japan and England had different ways they treated women and because of that the Japanese women accepted almost everything they went through in the mills. In Japan the women were

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    As for the workers from both Japan and India, they were treated fairly different. They worked twelve to fourteen hours days with no breaks pushing a pedal to spin the spindles. Most of the came from farming communities that didn’t have any more work. They worked for cheap and had long, tedious hours for little money. When a family had a surplus in workers on their farm they would send them to the factories. Even though the worker is technically owned and making money for the farm, they are not in direct correlation with the family. (doc.5 ) The textile factories in India were cleaner and more safe than those in Japan because of their cleanliness.(doc.10) In a Japanese textile factory a thirteen year old girl’s sister was killed from an illness that she had caught from the factory. The young girl blamed the disgusting living conditions and hard labor forced upon them all. (doc. 3) This point of view is a good look into Japanese factories because the girl had firsthand experience in the factories.…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Industrial Revolution started in Western Europe, specifically in Britain, but other countries were soon quickly caught up with Britain to lead the industry. At that time, Japan was isolated them from Europe, however later they were forced to open the door by the U.S government. Instead of resisting, the Japanese began to follow other countries in the industry. Silk factories were part of their industry; they hired female women, especially young girls to work in their silk factories. The costs did not outweigh the benefits the female workers in Japanese silk factories during the early 1900’s because workers were working under harsh and inhuman conditions, with amount of hours they work the wages are really low and it was out of choice to work…

    • 1160 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Female Mill Workers in England and Japan were indeed quite different. Workers in Japan had lower incomes and there were more young female workers. England had higher wages and the ages varied. Through the eleven documents, one can see that they can be broken into four categories, showing the differences between the two countries. The four categories being background information, gender and age, wages and hours, and working conditions. Through these eleven documents one can see that Female Mill Workers in Japan and England were different.…

    • 917 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cotton Industry Dbq Essay

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Poor conditions and low pay developed for workers in both countries, especially in japan. Girls were forced to work late in confined space and pay was sparse, on top of that sickness was common and some died from diseases spread in the factories (doc.3). However despite low pay, factory jobs were important for many lower class or farmer families. Many would send their children to work in the factories to provide extra income to their family (doc.4). Also factory jobs provided an escape from those same lower class strata’s for the girls who went to work as they became responsible for themselves and weren’t held back forced to provide for an entire family (doc. 5). This same effect was true in India where the vast majority of workers were recruited from small rural farming villages (doc.9). These similarities are clearly defined as inherent aspects of industrialization in a non-industrialized…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When looking at the difference at the backgrounds from female workers from Japan and England the show few similitarities between these two areas. In Document #1 England of Japan (Maps), the point of view of this document is that it shows a current map to compare the similar size of the two countries; they both are small island nations. Document #2 Mill Workers: Two Visuals, point of view from this document shows that the two pictures show that life in a factory or mill may seem all nice and clean, but as proof from the other documents shows this is not so. They give the deception of the mills and factories being too good to be true. These pictures also show the majority of female workers, with minimal male interaction. One can infer from the deception that these are advertisements for factories in different areas. A few additional documents that would help better explain the background of the experiences of female workers; One would be a bigger map that shows the entire world, and one that shows real photos of the factories that are not staged or propaganda. Through these two documents we can see that even though there are numerous differences between the female workers in the island nations of Japan and England, there are still a few similarities.…

    • 1922 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cotton Industry Dbq

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages

    There is a chart (Doc 7) that compares the amount of female cotton textile workers in Japan and India. It shows that over three-fourths were women in Japan, and less than one-fourth of Indian laborers were women. Another way this document helps show the difference of workers between Japanese and Indian textile factories is that in Japan the percent of women workers slightly increases over the years 1920-1930. In India, the percent of female workers from 1909-1934 decreases, meaning women didn’t work as much in factories. Because India was so patriarchal the women’s job was to stay home and take care of the house. Document 4 is a written concern about how there are many women working in Japanese textile mills. Documents 8 and 10 both consist of a picture from a Japanese cotton mill (Doc 8), and an Indian textile mill (Doc 10). The Japanese mill (Doc 8) illustrates a couple of women working and two or three men just sitting there (most likely supervising.) However in difference to Japan, the Indian mill (Doc 10) shows only male workers, this helps prove that more men worked than women in Indian textile mills. One should approach document 8 with caution because the source seems to be unreliable. The photo is from and official company history, meaning the picture was most likely staged to make it look like a superior place to…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Europe, women were responsible for certain activities and were also treated with respect, while in Japan, they were entirely serving men. The European women were expected to stay home and be trained in household chores, such as farming or sewing, and they didn’t have an option to chose who they want to marry. On the other hand, the Japanese women held a more equal status as Japanese men. For example, the Japanese women were allowed to inherit part of their family’s estate and some women even became Samurais. The use of a feudal system in Japan affected their women by becoming more equal, while in Europe, they were only valued for their work and what they did. Women enjoyed a higher role and status in Japan at the time, due to the feudal…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Women were reminded that they were not to fill these jobs permanently but only for the time being until the men came back home. Men did not want women “to cheapen the industry or to take the jobs of the men for the whole of the future”. In 1944 a Labour Department survey illustrated that only 28% of women wanted to leave their jobs and return to the household after the war. Few Women worked after WW2 but many didn’t, those that stayed in the work force were paid significantly less then men even when they were doing the same job. Many of the women who went back to the household chose that because they did not want the jobs that were available to them.…

    • 2279 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Women were driven out of their jobs, due to the fields they chose to face hostility from the men and that there are unwritten laws of advancement belonging to men, and that to be a woman in these fields would be so much of a fight that women would just go home to a job that welcomed them…that after the war, many women did work, there were plenty of jobs, but the jobs that required training and that were actual professions besides, a factory job.”…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The book Hiroshima by John Hersey describes the life of people after the dropping of the bomb and the different roles they had to fulfill after the bomb in order to survive. The women in the book are forced to do several tasks that were normally male dominated in order to bring home enough money to feed their families. One woman that demonstrates this is is Nakamura-San, who works in a chemical shop wrapping mothballs. This task was difficult for her and all the other workers because “Paragen had a dizzying odor, and at first it made one’s eyes smart” which added to her already difficult situation of being an atomic bomb victim (Hersey 96). Although she often got sick from work, she had no other option other than to work a difficult job as…

    • 173 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In addition, some women were fired after the war because their jobs were seen as “untraditional,” while men were not fired for doing the same jobs. Moreover, women were simply used for the war effort and were disregarded after it ended. Furthermore, the benefits women were given were not fair compared to their male counterparts. For instance, when women took over the jobs men left, women munitions workers were only earning 50 - 83% of what their male coworkers were earning (Freeman-Shaw 19). Additionally, a significant number of black women did not work in industrial labour until long after World War I (Freeman-Shaw 19).…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Poorer women had to manage families and work in factories at the same time to make ends meet. With the gender roles present, women would be expected to manage the household without any help regardless of whether they also had jobs or outside affairs, since the participation in those activities in addition to the duties she was expected to fulfill would be seen as a choice. Having these…

    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Help wanted! Long hours! Low pay! Unfair labor contracts! How could you turn us down? This might seem crazy but many people wouldn’t turn them down. They needed work and a paycheck. Even though the workers paid very little money and had long hours they still worked because once you’re in it’s hard to get out. So, did the cost outweigh the benefits for female Japan silk workers? The cost outweighed the benefits for three reasons: long, hard hours, low and unfair pay, and finally, unfair labor contracts.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    5.2.4 Businesswoman

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The door for a woman in the business world might have been opened, but it was difficult for her to demonstrate her worth. A woman was required to take the same education as a man, even though they ended with the same grades, a woman’s university degree counted as almost nothing, the degree did not have value for the Japanese companies, and they continued to only hire men for higher positions. The change of this came with the foreign companies. They noticed numerous of benefits by hiring the overqualified Japanese women; they were able to save money by hiring women, compared to men. The women then began to rise in the business world, and slowly they began to overtake several of the positions previously only taken by men (Murphy,…

    • 1235 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First is open-minded. Although Japan has been influenced a lot by western culture, most people still stick to the conservative concept-female should stay at home, not go outside to work. In 2007, Japan's GEM(United Nations Development Program's Gender Empowerment Measure, which gauges equality by tracking woman's participation in politics and business) was ranked 54th out of 93 countries. Japanese should be open-minded and encourage female to work. If female work, their talent and education can be best made use of. What is more, since males and females are complementary in many aspects, their cooperations with males can propel economic development more effectively.…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays